How is Fault Determined for Car Accident Claims
Who is the At-Fault Driver in a Car Accident?
Determination of fault after a car accident in Queensland has consequences for who is liable to pay damages. The accident scene largely determines responsibility for motor vehicle accidents, particularly in terms of the location of vehicle damage and other available physical evidence.
Our legal guide breaks down the fault determination process following a car accident and offers straightforward advice to protect your legal and financial interests.
Legal Advice About Car Accident Fault
If you have been injured in a motor vehicle accident and are not the at-fault driver, the Motor Accident Insurance Act protects your right to claim compensation for financial loss. But it’s not always straightforward to know who is at fault for a car crash, and the CTP insurance company might assign you contributory negligence.
The Car Accident Compensation Lawyers QLD provides a free advice that can explain the following:
- Who is to blame for the accident
- Eligibility to claim compensation
- Your rights and entitlements
- Our genuine 100% no-win, no-fee, no-risk policy
- Your next steps
Our road accident compensation team offers a genuine 100% no-win, no-fee policy. Pay only when you win and nothing if you lose. It’s free to learn your legal options. Call 1800 860 777
Free Claim Review
About Fault Determination
in Queensland
Determining fault in a car accident is key, as it directly affects legal liability and has significant financial repercussions for the drivers and vehicles involved in the collision. First, know that there are different types of faults for motor vehicle accidents, including:
First, know there are different types of faults for motor vehicle accidents, including:
- A clear-cut fault occurs when one driver is entirely responsible for an accident, such as a rear-end car crash. Almost always, the driver of the car behind is to blame.
- Contributory negligence or shared fault.
- Blameless accidents: When a medical emergency, a mechanical failure, or an animal running across the road causes a collision, neither party is considered at fault.
- Evidence such as eyewitness statements and vehicle damage assessments can significantly influence fault determination in car accidents.
- When determining fault, traffic violations and signs of negligence are essential factors considered by police and insurance companies.
- The police can issue reports that detail contributing factors to the accident, which can be crucial for insurance claims.
Don’t Admit Fault!
NOTE: Apologising is admitting fault in a car crash. It is essential not to admit fault at the scene of an accident to protect your legal position during claims negotiations.
The Role of Traffic Laws
Traffic laws help determine fault in car accidents because traffic violations are primary indicators of fault. For instance, a driver who breaches traffic laws by failing to obey red lights or stop signs, or by exceeding the speed limit, is to blame if they cause a car crash while breaching road rules.
In many accidents, assessing who broke QLD road rules or was driving carelessly is necessary to establish fault. Fortunately, a traffic accident report includes details such as:
- Adherence to speed limits
- Traffic light compliance
- And other potential breaches
Importance of Evidence
Establishing fault in a car accident can be challenging because it usually depends on the limited evidence available. As a result, after exchanging contact details with the other driver involved in the accident, you should collect evidence such as:
- Taking photographs and videos of vehicle damage
- Police reports and infringement notices
- Witness statements
- Damage to your own car and the other party’s vehicle
- You should also document skid marks and other relevant road features.
This is because witness statements help establish who was responsible for the accident and can significantly support your evidence in a car accident claim.
In Queensland, police often go to accident scenes and write reports with information that helps determine fault.
Who Decides Responsibility
for a Motor Vehicle Accident?
A motor vehicle accident typically involves only one driver, but it may also involve multiple drivers. However the accident happened, at least one CTP insurance company is responsible for paying insurance claim damages. Consequently, the insurer will assign an investigator to decide who it believes is the at-fault driver. This process can involve
- Interviews with all parties involved in the road accident
- Accessing eyewitness statements
- Reviewing CCTV footage and photos
- Viewing police reports
- Considering traffic violations like ignoring traffic lights or signs, or failing to take reasonable care
When an insurer disputes a claim, a court might decide who is liable for damages.
Do I Have a Valid Claim?
Steps to Determine Fault
in a Car Accident
Determining fault for a motor vehicle accident involves considering several factors, including the following:
- How the accident occurred
- Was there a breach of traffic rules?
- Did someone fail to keep a proper lookout?
- Was someone injured?
- Did someone accept responsibility?
- The location of the vehicle damage
Collecting Information at the Accident Scene
Information from the accident scene can often help identify the at-fault driver. This information can include:
- The road and weather conditions at the time of the crash
- The location of traffic lights and signals
- Eyewitness accounts
- Road markings like tyre tracks and skid marks
- Surrounding property damage
Police Reports
Police attend an accident scene when there are injuries or significant vehicle damage (requiring towing). If they don’t attend, you should make a police report by phone or at your local police station, particularly when:
- A driver fails to (or won’t) exchange details
- A driver appears to be under the influence of alcohol or drugs
- The other driver has likely breached road rules
A traffic accident report is helpful for any future legal action and is available if police investigate a road incident. This document is the most common way of determining who may be at fault.
Determining Fault by Location of Vehicle Damage
An insurance investigator or the police can often determine who was at fault by examining the cars involved in the crash and interviewing the people involved. They can work out the direction and speed of the vehicles before the collision by looking at:
- Tyre marks on the road
- Photos and videos of the vehicles’ positions
- The extent and location of damage on each vehicle
- The deformation patterns on the vehicles’ bodies
- The point of impact and how the cars came to rest after the collision
By analysing these factors, experts can reconstruct the accident to determine which driver likely caused the crash or contributed to it. For example:
- Damage on the front of one vehicle and the rear of another often indicates a rear-end collision, where the driver who hits from behind is usually at fault.
- A failure to yield or a violation of a red light may be indicated by side-impact damage.
- Severe vehicle damage may indicate that the driver was travelling at higher speeds or recklessly.
It’s Free to Know Your Rights
Key Parties in Fault Determination
The three main parties involved in fault determination are
- Insurance companies
- Police officers
- Personal injury lawyers
Each of the above plays a distinct role in the process, from investigating the accident to providing legal advice and representation for all drivers involved.
CTP or Comprehensive Insurance Companies
CTP insurers are generally liable for damages resulting from a motor vehicle accident, and they will attempt to protect their financial interests. Assigning a greater degree of fault to the other driver decreases their financial liability for the accident. Consequently, insurance providers will look into cases by:
- Interviewing drivers
- Collecting eyewitness accounts
- Examining evidence like CCTV footage and photos of the vehicles involved
- Reviewing compensation claim forms and police reports
They often attempt to attribute a higher degree of contributory negligence to the claimant, as this lowers the amount they have to pay in damages.
Police Officers
Police reports include details of traffic offences, weather conditions, and other contributory factors that can affect the outcome of fault determination. These reports are vitally important in cases of serious injury.
Police investigations consider the location of vehicle damage, road markings, driver behaviour and CCTV footage to determine what happened during the accident and offer vital information for a fault assessment.
Legal Representation
QLD personal injury laws protect your right to seek legal advice after an accident. A personal injury lawyer can assist with determining fault for a motor vehicle accident.
The Car Accident Compensation Lawyers QLD provides a free case review that can explain the following:
- Eligibility to claim fair compensation for a road accident.
- The process of determining fault for your case
- Our 100% no-financial-risk guarantee
Pay only for a win and nothing if you lose. Call 1800 860 777
How The Accident Happened:
Determining Fault
If you are a person involved in a motor vehicle accident, your next question might be, “Who is the at-fault driver?” Sometimes, how the accident occurred helps determine who is responsible for the collision. Below are some common scenarios.
Rear-end collisions
Typically, the driver who strikes another vehicle from behind is considered liable for a rear-end accident.
- When one driver merges into another lane without enough space, both drivers can share responsibility for a rear-end collision.
- According to QLD road rules, drivers must maintain a safe distance from the vehicle in front to prevent rear-end collisions, which ensures the safety of all road users.
Intersection accidents
In Queensland, when you stop at a T-intersection, you lose priority to oncoming traffic.
- This rule applies regardless of whether there is a traffic sign or lights.
- You may proceed when there is a green light or when it is safe to do so at intersections without lights.
As a result, the driver who does not have the right-of-way is typically at fault for an intersection crash, unless one of the following conditions applies:
- The other driver was speeding
- The other driver was changing lanes at the intersection.
- It was dark, and the other vehicle had damaged lights.
- The other driver was under the influence or distracted.
Who is at fault if I reverse into a car?
Generally, the driver of the reversing car is at fault when they collide with another vehicle, especially if they hit the rear end of another car.
- If both vehicles were moving at the same time, they could both be responsible for the accident.
- If a stationary car is rear-ended while reversing, the other driver is usually considered at fault.
- Drivers have a responsibility to ensure they are clear of other vehicles and pedestrians before reversing to avoid liability.
Fault when a car hits you and you hit another car
Determining fault is more complex when a car hits you and, as a result, you collide with another vehicle. Generally, fault for multi-vehicle collisions is assigned by considering
- The sequence of events
- Each driver’s degree of responsibility in causing the initial impact and subsequent collisions
If the first driver hits you from behind, they are typically considered at fault for the initial collision. However, if your vehicle then strikes another car, fault for the second collision may depend on whether you had enough time and space to stop safely or avoid the collision.
If you and the other drivers share responsibility for the chain of events, contributory negligence may apply.
3-car pileup: who's at fault?
If there are three or more cars in a pileup, the vehicle that hits another car from behind will still be at fault, unless it was also hit from behind.
In most cases, the last vehicle in the chain that triggered the collision will be held responsible for the entire accident, as they had the chance to prevent it from occurring.
Who is to Blame for a Hire Car Accident?
In a hire car accident, the hire car company’s insurance typically covers damage to the rental vehicle. However, you might be responsible for paying an excess amount, and the driver of the other vehicle can make a claim against you if you are at fault.
If you are at fault in a hire car accident:
- A hire car insurance policy will likely cover vehicle damage
- You will be liable for repair costs depending on the policy terms
- You may be responsible for the excess amount specified in your rental agreement.
- The hire car company’s insurance may pursue you or the insurer for repair costs.
If you are not at fault in a rental car accident:
- Any damage to the rental car should be covered by the hire company’s insurance or third-party property insurance.
- Injuries may be covered by compulsory third-party (CTP) insurance.
Special Considerations
to Determine Liability
Some scenarios require special consideration when determining fault.
- Blameless accidents caused by unexpected mechanical failures
- A motor vehicle accident occurred when an employee was driving to or from work.
- Multi-vehicle crashes
Blameless Accidents
In Queensland, a blameless accident happens when neither driver bears any fault. Examples include:
- A driver having a heart attack or stroke while driving
- A vehicle has an unexplained failure.
- An animal running onto the road (unless the animal’s owner failed to take reasonable care)
These are classified as blameless because the accident happened due to circumstances beyond the drivers’ control.
Multiple Vehicle Collisions
In multiple-vehicle collisions, fault is typically shared among the drivers, with more than one person being held partially or fully responsible. Unless pushed from behind, the first driver in a concertina collision usually assumes liability for the injured parties.
When more than one driver is at fault, there may be more than one person responsible for paying damages, each with their own level of liability.
Accident in My Own Car While Driving for Work Purposes
When you are driving your own vehicle to or from work (or for work purposes) and are involved in an accident, the situation regarding fault and liability can be complex.
If you were performing work duties at the time of the accident, your employer may face liability in certain cases, and you could be eligible to claim workers’ compensation benefits.
However, your employer is less likely to bear responsibility if you were driving for personal reasons or beyond the scope of your work duties.
CTP Insurance Claim Process
and Seeking Compensation
Eligibility for claiming compensation for a car accident depends on whether the other driver was at fault. Conversely, if you are at fault, the other driver may claim against your CTP insurance policy.
Strict time limits apply to car insurance claims, so it’s essential to take action. During this process:
- You should notify the driver of the other car that you intend to claim damages for property damage soon after the accident.
- Insurance companies will review submitted claims and related documentation to determine liability.
- Negotiation and settlement will occur after the claim has been filed.
- You should consider reaching a legal agreement with the responsible party to settle claims without going to court (as there can be considerable additional legal costs).
About Contributory Negligence
Insurance companies often determine fault by considering the available evidence, which usually includes witness statements and police reports.
- When both drivers are found to have contributed to an accident, each party’s contributory negligence affects the amount of compensation paid in a settlement.
- In contributory negligence scenarios, liability is shared between the involved drivers based on their respective degrees of fault.
Legal Advice for Car Accident
Compensation Claims
QLD personal injury laws protect your right to obtain legal advice after a car accident, including the identification of the at-fault driver. A car accident lawyer can also:
- Help you understand your rights regarding common law compensation
- Explain the claims process and how to collect evidence
- Detail ways to eliminate or reduce contributory negligence.
- Negotiate with insurance companies on your behalf.
- Explain how to prepare written statements
NOTE: It is advisable not to admit fault at the scene of the accident to protect your legal position. You should also keep copies of all correspondence related to your accident, including:
- Letters, emails, and text messages with the drivers involved
- Insurance company communications
- Receipts of medical expenses
- Medical reports and documentation
If negotiations with insurance companies fail to result in a fair settlement, a law firm can explain your options for seeking damages through the courts.
Free Claim Review
Car Accident Fault Determination
Rules QLD FAQs
What if more than one driver caused the motor vehicle accident?
Determining fault can be more complicated in a motor vehicle accident involving multiple drivers. In such cases, each driver is typically assigned a level of contributory negligence, which affects their eligibility and the amount of compensation.
What should I do immediately after a car accident to help determine fault?
Immediately after a car accident, you should follow these steps:
- Collect detailed information from all parties involved, including names, addresses, and driver’s license details
- Get witness contact information, if possible
- Take photographs of the scene and document everything to help support determination of fault.
- Contact the police if the other driver appears to be under the influence of drugs or alcohol
- Note if the other party apologises for the collision
How do traffic laws affect fault determination in a car crash?
New South Wales and QLD traffic laws can help decide who is at fault in a car accident by setting standards for expected driver behaviour.
For example, a traffic violation (such as speeding or running a red light) typically indicates negligent driver behaviour, increasing the likelihood of being held responsible for damage caused in a car accident.
How do you tell who is in the wrong in a car accident?
To determine who is at fault in a car accident, you need to closely examine the available evidence and the road rules.
Often, the process of establishing who is responsible for the accident is supported by the liable CTP insurer and the police, using the available evidence.
Will a car insurance company pay out if it was my fault?
If you have comprehensive car insurance, you should be covered for property damage after a car accident, even if you were the at-fault driver.
However, you may have to pay an excess, and your premiums will probably increase.
